Pedro Antonio Mato Narbondo, known by the nickname “El Burro,” is a former Uruguayan Army officer whose name became associated with one of the major international judicial cases concerning crimes committed during South America’s military dictatorships.
Narbondo served in Uruguay’s armed forces during the 1970s and was connected to the country’s intelligence and counterinsurgency apparatus. Historical accounts identify him as having worked with the Defense Intelligence Service, known as SID, and the Coordinating Organization of Anti-Subversive Operations, or OCOA. His activities were connected to the wider system of political repression that operated in Uruguay and across the Southern Cone during the era of Operation Condor.
The nickname “El Burro” has been attributed to his military colleagues and was associated in later reporting with the way he conducted interrogations. Reports about his role have included allegations of participation in clandestine detention operations, interrogations and abuses against political opponents during the dictatorship. These historical allegations should be distinguished from the specific acts for which he was ultimately convicted by an Italian court.
Narbondo became the subject of international judicial proceedings because of Operation Condor, a coordinated system of intelligence and repression involving several South American dictatorships. The Italian case focused on crimes committed against Italian citizens and people with Italian nationality in Argentina during the 1970s.
In July 2019, the Milan Court of Appeal sentenced Narbondo to life imprisonment for his participation in qualified intentional homicides committed in Argentina in June 1976. The conviction was later upheld by Italy’s highest court and became final in July 2021. According to judicial records cited by Brazil’s Superior Court of Justice, the conviction concerns Narbondo’s co-perpetration in the killings of four people in Argentina.
The Italian proceedings were particularly significant because they established criminal responsibility in a case involving repression that crossed national borders. The victims were connected to Italy, allowing Italian courts to exercise jurisdiction over crimes committed outside the country.
Narbondo later acquired Brazilian nationality through his Brazilian mother. Because Brazilian law does not permit the extradition of a Brazilian national, Italy requested that Brazil recognize and enforce the Italian sentence domestically.
The issue reached Brazil’s Superior Court of Justice, or STJ. In April 2026, the court began examining Italy’s request to transfer execution of the sentence to Brazil. The STJ emphasized that the proceeding does not reopen the merits of the Italian conviction; instead, the Brazilian court is examining the legal requirements for recognizing the foreign judgment.
The reporting judge, Justice Sebastião Reis Júnior, voted to recognize the Italian judgment and transfer execution of the sentence to Brazil, while converting the life sentence to a maximum of 30 years of imprisonment, consistent with Brazilian law. The judgment was suspended after Justice Maria Isabel Gallotti requested additional time to examine the case.
While the case remains pending, the STJ imposed precautionary measures on Narbondo. He was prohibited from leaving Santana do Livramento, Rio Grande do Sul, placed under electronic monitoring, required to surrender his passport and included on federal lists used to control movement near the international border.
The Narbondo case illustrates how Operation Condor continued to have legal consequences decades after the South American dictatorships ended. It also demonstrates the difficulties involved when a person convicted abroad holds Brazilian nationality and cannot be extradited.
As of 2026, Narbondo remains subject to a final Italian conviction for the homicides covered by that case, while the Brazilian proceedings concerning the domestic execution of that sentence had not yet reached a final conclusion.
SOURCES
Superior Court of Justice of Brazil — STJ
STJ: 2026 judgment on the execution of Narbondo’s Italian sentence
Superior Court of Justice of Brazil — STJ
STJ: Italy’s request to enforce the sentence in Brazil
Supreme Federal Court of Brazil — STF
STF: Narbondo and the Operation Condor conviction
Presidency of Uruguay
Uruguay: Italian appellate conviction in the Operation Condor case
Plan Condor
Final Italian Supreme Court verdict in the Operation Condor trial
